The ever-changing circumstances of life demand that Allama Muhammad Iqbal's claim that his poetry is an interpretation of the Quran and Sunnah be re-examined. Since the publication of his first poetic collection, Bang-e-Dara, until now, so much has been written about his philosophy that some critics say there's nothing left to explore. We believe that the existing critiques should be re-evaluated.With this aim, we revisited our notes on Bang-e-Dara on its centennial anniversary. These writings helped us understand how Iqbal's ideas had once filled us with conviction and confidence, but also led to doubts and uncertainty at times.If we had been convinced that Iqbal's poetry possessed universality, we could have spent the rest of our lives with that conviction. However, as we delved deeper into research, we were faced with an endless array of questions. It was then that we decided to engage in a direct dialogue with Iqbal through Bang-e-Dara.Due to the vastness of the topics covered in this poetic collection, it was impossible to discuss them all in this brief article. Therefore, we selected a few poems and ghazals to ask Iqbal how he can guide us in the modern era. We also asked if new events could diminish his impact. This article attempts to find answers to these questions and more.